There are many talented acts competing to win Season 11 of America’s Got Talent. Sadly some of our favorites went before their time. However, it’s arguable that the true stars of the show are the judges. We once again have Simon Cowell, Howie Mandel, Melanie Brown (Mel B), and Heidi Klum back to narrow down the acts before America starts voting.
It’s true that everyone has their favorite judge, but which ones are truly the best and the worst? A good judge is someone who is able to balance entertaining the audience at home, while actually giving valuable feedback to the contestants.
Sometimes this balance is thrown out of whack by a judge. Other times they’re just not able to do their job to the best of their abilities given their experience. So how do the four current judges on the show stack up? Below is where we rate the America’s Got Talent judges, starting from the best and moving down to the worst.